I am the primary to confess I like Lightroom. Certain, it has its points, like sometimes sluggish efficiency on good {hardware} and an admittedly ageing interface, however I am snug with it. There are a selection of duties, although, that you just simply should not be utilizing Lightroom for. Wish to know what they’re?


One which I most lately observed, when engaged on plenty of architectural images, was Lightroom’s lackluster assist for remodel/upright corrections. Certain, you may make these corrections, however between Lightroom’s slower rendering efficiency and lack of choices for rescaling, I used to be at all times upset. I discovered that I used to be dropping the sides of my body, with none option to repair it. Bringing these images over to Photoshop made issues a lot simpler. I may rescale my canvas to keep away from dropping the sides, fill in small gaps with content material conscious fill, and iterate via the method extra rapidly. Now, the most effective resolution would simply be to purchase a tilt-shift lens, however till then, I will do my architectural corrections in Photoshop.


It is not simply images of buildings, however images of individuals. Whereas correct pores and skin tones are an entire new situation, let’s discuss retouching first. Lightroom is missing assist for vital retouching capabilities, which is comprehensible. What I am unhappy to see is simply how unhealthy the fundamental retouching and cloning scenario is. 

Lightroom is ok for cloning one or two mud spots out of a sky, however for something extra, the spot software is lower than the duty. With many corrections, it slows to a crawl (noticing a theme?), whereas for big corrections, it lacks the management and flexibility of the therapeutic brush, clone stamp, content material conscious fill, and the patch software. Moreover, in case you’re a talented retouching artist and are attempting to work with frequency separation, Lightroom has nothing of relevance to supply. For something greater than a lone mud spot or errant zit, you will wish to deliver your photographs over to Photoshop for any retouching.

The comb and gradient masks instruments, proper close to the spot therapeutic software, are one other instance of Lightroom’s pores and skin deep function set. Luminosity and shade masking had been added some time in the past, however are removed from the whole package deal. Each are comparatively sluggish to preview, with out a lot risk of refinement. In comparison with a devoted panel or plugin in Photoshop, they too are solely good for small changes.


One other instance of Lightroom’s half-measured assist falling brief is panorama stitching. Whereas I like the thought of Lightroom retaining all of your uncooked info all through the sew, Lightroom solely helps a really slim use case. Primarily, it is advisable be taking pictures a textbook panorama. Good rotation across the nodal level, no shifting components, no parallax points; when you’ve got one thing even barely off, you will spend a minute ready on a progress bar, simply to see an error message.

I’ve had far more success enhancing one file, syncing the adjustments throughout, and exporting to sew in a devoted program. Whereas I lose a few of the flexibility of the uncooked information, the significantly better stitching efficiency makes up for it. Lightroom nonetheless does not make this workflow simple, since you must be sure that to set a customized white stability and lens corrections to keep away from inconsistencies within the stitched shot. Whether or not you are utilizing Hugin, PTGui, or simply Photoshop, you will recognize the higher management over your sew.


Coloration changes, significantly for studio or portraiture work, have at all times been a energy of Seize One. Whereas I have never had the chance to work extensively with Seize One, its options and repute make it the clear selection for this type of work. Help for intensive shade matching, by way of the Xrite ColorChecker Passport, goes far past Lightroom’s HSL and white stability instruments. Moreover, Seize One helps devoted panels for pores and skin tone changes, making it a greater software for tweaking the colour of portraits. Whereas my work does not sometimes contain these instruments, I’ve seen different photographers use them to nice impact.

Past working with uncooked shade, many customers simply want the default look of different uncooked processing software program. Previous testing has proven you can generate an virtually similar look with any program, however for a lot of customers, attending to that desired look with the fewest steps is most well-liked. I did not have a powerful place on this situation previously, however Lightroom seems to work together weirdly with some settings on my Z 7. Apart from locking a few of the profile corrections on, I discover that my uncooked information do not look like as impartial, requiring both adjustments to the default settings or profile. Whereas I’ve since labored out a default profile I like, I do not take pleasure in how Adobe approached this transformation.


One of many traditional differentiators for Lightroom has been layer assist, or lack thereof. Whereas this was fantastic 5 years in the past, instances have modified. Lightroom’s competitors, like Seize One and Affinity Photograph, have introduced layer assist to the social gathering. Different instruments, like Skylum Luminar, additionally supply some type of layer assist, though to not the identical extent as Photoshop.

As I’ve come to rely extra on layers and as my workflow has developed through the years, the dearth of layer assist is actually beginning to stick out. I would like to see an implementation of layers into Lightroom’s non-destructive enhancing type, however I dread to consider the efficiency influence it could deliver. Till then, it appears Management+E goes to nonetheless be my pal.

The roundtrip workflow between Lightroom and Photoshop has been fantastic, however does not really feel as environment friendly because it might be. Having to leap over to Photoshop simply to make use of layers feels pointless, since an rising variety of instruments have come over to Lightroom, not less than in some type. The left aspect panel within the Develop module appears like a pure match for a layers menu. It already consists of historical past and preset assist. Layers, together with higher masking assist, may go an extended option to slicing down my want for Photoshop.


Lightroom cannot do every part for each kind of photographer. In the event you’re a devoted studio shooter, you are in all probability already tethering with Seize One. In the event you’re sad with the pricing mannequin, possibly you’ve got given another product a strive. In the event you’re like me, having used Lightroom for years, you’ve got grown used to a few of the peculiarities. I positively nonetheless see worth in Lightroom, nonetheless. Significantly as a part of the pictures plan, Photoshop and Lightroom can cowl photographers of each ability stage and elegance, even when you must depend on each apps for the whole image.

I’ve used it for years, for each private {and professional} work, and have not been too sad with it. I like the devoted catalog and skill to return to refine a years-old shot at any time. I’ve gotten snug with the interface and quirks from years of working with it. Mixed with my catalog going again years, I’ve received fairly a little bit of lock-in. Options like keywording, GPS assist, and the broad (if a bit shallow) number of enhancing instruments means I can do 90% of my work in Lightroom. For that final 10%, nonetheless, I am relying extra on exterior instruments, and it appears that evidently 10% is simply rising, regardless of Lightroom’s updates.

Talking of updates, Adobe has lately launched an replace for ACR and Lightroom that gives improved efficiency and GPU processing assist for plenty of instruments. In my preliminary testing, issues have gotten a bit snappier. I would nonetheless prefer to see plenty of function updates, however I agree with Adobe’s path in addressing efficiency first.


fbq(‘init’, ‘938393452883301’);
fbq(‘track’, “PageView”);(function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = “https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.3”; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));

Shop Amazon